Gold Diggers of 1933 (1933)

Gold Diggers of 1933 is one of the great Warner Brothers pre-code musicals with wild Busby Berkeley production numbers.

The plot is your standard Warner Brothers pre-code backstage musical plot. Producer Barney Hopkins (Ned Sparks) is putting on a show or at least he’s trying to. But this is the Depression and the money needed to finance a show is simply impossible to find. The show closes before it even opens.

Polly Parker (Ruby Keeler), Fay Fortune (Ginger Rogers), Carol King (Joan Blondell) and Trixie Lorraine (Aline MacMahon) are broke again. They’re in utter despair until Barney announces that he has a new show ready to go. But as usual, he has everything he needs except the money.

The girls’ neighbour, Brad (Dick Powell), then offers to finance the show. Since he’s a penniless aspiring songwriter nobody takes him seriously. But somehow he comes up with the money.

Barney wants Brad to be the juvenile lead but Brad tells him that it is simply not possible for him to perform in public.

Then we get the classic Warner Brothers backstage musical scene. The juvenile lead cannot go on. The show is doomed. The only hope is for Brad to go on.

Brad and Polly have already fallen hopelessly in love. They decide to get married.

Things get complicated when Brad’s real identity is revealed and his brother J. Lawrence Bradford (Warren William) arrives on the scene intent on preventing the marriage.

We then get plenty of farce with identities getting mixed up and the girls cooking up a plot to make sure that true love triumphs.

Warren William was always at his best when he could be really slimy and oily. In this movie he’s basically not such a bad guy, which may disappoint some of his fans.

Aline MacMahon is the out-and-out comic character and overdoes things a bit. Guy Kibbee is fun (as always) as J. Lawrence Bradford’s lawyer who has a weakness for the ladies. Ned Sparks is terrific. Ruby Keeler is as sweet as ever but she could get away with being sweet. Joan Blondell and Ginger Rogers are excellent.

What I love about these Busby Berkeley musicals is that they have theatrical settings and the musical production numbers are supposedly taking place on stage. But these numbers could never be accommodated on a stage and they could never be watched on stage since they can only be appreciated when viewed through the camera’s eye. As soon as the musical production numbers start we are teleported from the world of the theatre into a world of pure cinema.

These are also production numbers that could only work in black-and-white. They need the artificiality of black-and-white. We are in a world of total artifice.

They would also look terribly crass in colour. This is a kind of glamour that only great black-and-white cinematography can provide.

Barney’s show is intended as a show about the Depression and Gold Diggers of 1933 is a movie about the Depression. It’s at its best in the early stages when we see Barney and the showgirls refusing to admit defeat. They’re show people and regardless of the obstacles they’re going to put on a show.

For many people the highlight is the Forgotten Man production number at the end. For me this number goes close to ruining the movie. It’s typical heavy-handed Warner Brothers “social commentary” and it’s like a political lecture clumsily tacked on at the end. These Warner Brother musicals work because they take us into a magical world of pure cinematic fantasy. The Forgotten Man number is out of place and a movie that should end on a playful joyful note ends in misery and whining.

As a result Gold Diggers of 1933 is the weakest of the Warner Brothers pre-code musicals but it does include three terrific production numbers. The Shadow Waltz is visually impressive. Pettin' in the Park is fabulous and inspired pre-code cheerful naughtiness. We're in the Money opens the movie and it’s the movie’s high point and it’s a great showcase for Ginger Rogers.

If you’re a Busby Berkeley newbie start with 42nd Street or Footlight Parade which are much better movies than this. Gold Diggers of 1933 has a few great moments but it doesn’t quite make it.

It’s annoying that this movie is available on Blu-Ray while the vastly superior Footlight Parade is not.