Under Eighteen (1931)

Under Eighteen (or Under 18) is a 1931 Warner Brothers romantic melodrama and it’s very much a Depression melodrama.

It begins in 1928 in the optimism and confidence of the Jazz Age. In New York the Evans family is prosperous.

Sophie Evans (Anita Page) has just married Alf (Norman Foster). He’s rather feckless but considers himself something of an entrepreneur. He owns a pool hall. In these pre-Stock Market Crash days business is booming and he looks forward to the day he will own a chain of pool halls.

Sophie’s sister Margie (Marian Marsh) is filled with romantic dreams.

Then comes the Depression. The Evans family is now broke. Alf has lost his pool hall and can’t find a job (partly because he still can’t adjust to the reality of no longer being a big shot and no longer being able to be his own boss).

Margie is expecting to marry Jimmy (Regis Toomey). He’s a delivery man. It’s not glamorous but at least it’s a job. Margie sees her future as an endless struggle against poverty. She’s dissatisfied and reckless. She’s jealous of Elsie (Dorothy Appleby). Elsie is a prostitute but she drives around in a limo and has beautiful clothes and jewellery and never has to worry where her next meal is coming from.

Margie still loves Jimmy, but she’s having doubts about marriage.

The marriage between Sophie and Alf is falling apart, Sophie needs money to pay for a divorce and the money cannot be found.

Margie is working at the fashion house of François (Paul Porcasi) but now she’s landed her big break - a modelling job. This is due to the interest taken in her by François’ biggest client, Raymond Harding (Warren William). Harding is fabulous rich, a notorious womaniser who has kept a string of mistresses and he’s just generally regarded as a very wicked man. He might be wicked, but Margie is now thinking that being nice to Harding might be her best option.

The cast is very strong. Regis Toomey and Norman Foster are very good. Anita Page is good as the increasingly desperate Sophie.

Warren Williams is in top form. Playing rich powerful men who are charming and sinister is what he did better than anyone.

Marian Marsh is excellent. She’s convincingly torn between her ingrained belief in respectability and the temptations of wickedness and she’s cute and likeable.

There’s no shortage of pre-code content. We have no doubt what any arrangement offered by Harding will entail. And there’s some amusing pre-code dialogue. When Margie arrives at Harding’s penthouse where a party is in full swing around the rooftop pool he says to her, “Why don’t you take your clothes off and stay awhile?”

A thing I like about pre-code movies is that this was the very beginning of the sound era and genre conventions for sound films had not yet solidified. As a result you’re always sure which way the plots will jump. In this case Under Eighteen could be heading for a tragic ending but could just as easily be heading for a feelgood happy ending. In fact the ending of this movie might seem dubious unless you remember that the movie doesn’t quite fit neatly into genre formulas that were established by the end of the decade. Not everyone will like the ending to this film but it works for me.

You also can’t predict which way the characters will go. All the characters here could be headed for disaster, but not necessarily. And they could turn out to less sympathetic, or more sympathetic, than they initially appeared to be. This is a movie that doesn’t rush to make moral judgments on the characters.

I thoroughly enjoyed Under Eighteen. Highly recommended.

The Warner Archive DVD looks very good.