The Only Game in Town (1970)

The Only Game in Town is a melodrama with some romantic comedy touches released by 20th Century Fox in 1970. It stars Elizabeth Taylor and Warren Beatty.

Fran Walker (Elizabeth Taylor) is a dancer in Vegas. She walks into a piano bar and gets chatted up by the piano player, Joe Grady (Warren Beatty). She’s lonely and they sleep together.

Each of them has a problem. Joe’s problem is gambling. He claims to have it under control. As soon as he has saved five thousand dollars he’s getting out of Vegas. But Joe is a gambler and while he can save money he can’t stop himself from gambling it away. For Joe getting out of Vegas is one of those things that seems like it’s just never going to happen.

Fran’s problem is her boyfriend Tom. He’s married. For five years he’s been promising Fran that he’ll divorce his wife and marry her. She’s given Tom an ultimatum, the latest of many. She hasn’t seen him for three months. For Fran marrying Tom is one of those things that seems like it’s just never going to happen.

Joe moves in with Fran. There’s no commitment. Each of them can just walk out of the relationship at any time. It’s not like it’s a big love affair. And they can’t make a commitment because any day now Joe will have that five grand and he’ll be off to New York, and any day now Tom will walk in and put an engagement ring on Fran’s finger.

Neither of them is going to admit to having fallen in love.

That’s pretty much the plot. The relationship is interesting and complex. We are told that Fran is three years older than Joe and in fact Taylor at 38 was a few years older than Beatty and that age difference is crucial to the story. Fran is obviously flattered that a good-looking younger man wants to get her into bed. Joe is an irresponsible overgrown boy. Fran finds herself mothering him. Joe is trying to deal with the fact that he’s found a woman he actually cares about.

Fran is desperately afraid of loneliness and she’s at the age where she can’t waste too much time on casual relationships. She’s afraid of losing Joe but she’s afraid of getting hurt if she makes a commitment. They both have some growing up to do.

I like the two central performances a great deal and the two leads have real chemistry. They play off each other amusingly and charmingly. They’re playing characters with very human weaknesses but Taylor and Beatty both make their characters sympathetic and likeable even when they’re doing exasperatingly foolish things.

The Only Game in Town was a spectacular box-office flop and ended the career of George Stevens as a director.

A large part of the problem is that this was 1970. Critics were wildly excited by the New American Cinema and by a new wave of young directors and stars who were going to revolutionise American movies. In the previous year Easy Rider and Midnight Cowboy came out. By comparison The Only Game in Town seemed very old-fashioned. George Stevens had been directing movies since 1933. This seemed like a movie that represented the glitz and glamour of 1950s Hollywood, the kind of old school movie that the New American Cinema was going to consign to the trash can.

Even worse, it has a definite 1950s melodrama feel. It has that 1950s major studio production polish. And critics had turned against Elizabeth Taylor. The whole Burton-Taylor celebrity circus thing hurt her career a good deal. In 1970 The Only Game in Town was inevitably going to be savaged by critics and ignored by the public.

Also counting against it was a hugely inflated budget. This should have been a modestly budgeted low-key intimate movie and as such would probably at least have broken even.

But classic movie fans today are less likely to be bothered by this movie’s old-fashioned feel. They’re more likely to see that as a plus. And old-fashioned melodramas have quite a following today.

Had this movie been released in the early 60s, around the time that movies like The World of Suzie Wong and Butterfield 8 were being made and Hollywood was tentatively moving towards grown-up movies about human relationships The Only Game in Town would probably have been hailed by critics as bold and daring. Timing is everything and the timing was wrong for this film in 1970.

It has to be said that Miss Taylor’s costumes are a major disaster and may have contributed to the dismissive attitudes towards the film.

I enjoyed The Only Game in Town. I’m going to recommend it.